Tonsil Stone Cryptolysis

by , last modified on 9/14/16
If you like this article, please comment below!

tonsil

What are tonsils stones? In a nutshell, they are small, foul-smelling pebbles that are produced and eventually pop out of the tonsils. They taste bad and smell even worse. Consider them kind of like acne of the tonsils. They occur at any age and can spontaneously come and go. (Read Washington Post article on this.)

Conservative treatment includes gargling, water pick rinses, and even manual expression to pop them out (typically with blunt end of toothbrush or a finger). Read more about non-surgical treatment here.

Then there is surgery...

First of all... we do offer laser cryptolysis, but ONLY if a few spots require treatment. If the "entire" tonsil surface needs to be treated, coblation is used instead. Coblation cryptolysis was developed by Dr. Chang and can be performed awake and using only local anesthesia (in most patients) in order to try and cure patients of tonsil stones (also known as tonsiloliths). Although there is no guarantee that this method will cure folks of tonsil stones (no more or less than laser cryptolysis), it is a less painful alternative method to consider and try before tonsillectomy which is the only known near 100% cure for tonsil stones (ie, as long as tonsils exist, there's always the potential for tonsil stones).

ADVANTAGES over tonsillectomy:

1) Can be done awake (without general anesthesia and intubation) in adult patients as long as there is:

  • minimal gag reflex (if you have a bad gag reflex, this will require general anesthesia and intubation)
  • tongue is not large
  • tonsil can be visualized easily when opening the mouth


2) Much less pain than traditional tonsillectomy
3) Faster recovery than traditional tonsillectomy

ADVANTAGES of Coblation Cryptolysis over Laser Cryptolysis:

1) Coblation can treat the entire tonsil surface quickly and completely. Laser can only address a few spots.
2) No risk of airway fire (if a spark occurs due to laser use, it can ignite the air)
3) No risk of blindness (laser can bounce off shiny surfaces like metal and reflect out and burn the retina)
4) No risk of oral and facial burns (lasers do not burn just the tonsil, it can burn anything that gets in the way... in other words, do NOT turn your head, sneeze, cough, or gag if the laser is turned on!!!)
5) No risk of inhaling the plume of vaporized tissue (which can cause airway burns as well as spread infection)
6) There's some question whether there is an increased risk of life-threatening bleeding with laser use, mainly because the laser can potentially pierce tissue like an arrow. Not an ideal characteristic because the carotid artery is < 1 cm away from the tonsil. Read an article about a boy who died after laser tonsillectomy due to this complication. The laser we use in our office is a 1064nm diode laser which works more on tissue contact rather than shooting out like a bullet like some other lasers.

DISADVANTAGES of Cryptolysis or Laser:

1) Continued problems with recurrent tonsillitis or strep throat (because with cryptolysis, there's always tonsil tissue left behind... only the crypt from which the stone develops is ablated.)
2) No pathology specimen to evaluate for lymphoma or tonsil cancer
3) Tonsil crypt regrowth (and therefore recurrence of stones)
4) Possible need to repeat procedure multiple times for effect
5) Does not necessarily make the tonsil smaller for those with large tonsils
6) At best, it only has an 80% chance of success (meaning this procedure will fail to resolve tonsil stones in 20%). The reason is because there are STILL tonsil tissue left behind with this procedure which can recreate the holes/pits where tonsil stones are produced.

To address tonsil stones, most patients (60-70%) require only a single session to get treated. However, 30-40% of patients require 2 or more sessions spread out over several months to get fully treated for tonsil stones. About 20% of patients may not respond to this method of treatment at all.

Please note that if there is any concern for tonsil cancer, tonsillectomy should be pursued. Cryptolysis should not be done as there is no pathological specimen obtained.

Who is the ideal patient for AWAKE coblation cryptolysis?

1) Adult patient
2) No or minimal gag reflex
3) Entire tonsil can be visualized when patient opens the mouth
4) Only a few (1-3) discrete areas where tonsil stones typically occur which can be easily seen when opening the mouth. If you have numerous areas of tonsil stone production, coblation tonsil resurfacing may need to be pursued (instead of laser). Tonsil stones produced at the base of the tonsil, in teh groove between tonsil and throat, and next to tongue are also difficult to address in an awake state.
5) Tonsil problems dealing mainly with tonsil stones or cryptic tonsils. Not chronic tonsillitis or strep throat.
6) No tonsil cancer concern

Great! I want a coblation cryptolysis performed! What do I do next?

Give us a call to make an appointment to get an evaluation done to see if you are a candidate! Awake coblation or laser cryptolysis IS covered by insurance that we participate with. An evaluation is required first prior to scheduling the procedure. Coblation cryptoloysis is ONLY performed on Friday afternoons. Laser cryptolysis can be performed during any clinic hours.

Procedure consent can be downloaded here. Post-procedure instructions can be downloaded here.


videoWatch Video on Tonsil Cryptolysis

The Procedure Steps:

cryptolysis

Step 1:

Local anesthesia is applied to the oropharynx and tonsils if done awake. If not, the patient is placed under general anesthesia.

Did you know that Dr. Chang was the medical expert for a PBS show on tonsil stones? Click for more info!

cryptolysis

Step 2:

Coblation is performed to the tonsil crypt where tonsil stones typically come from. The crypt is ablated with coblation such that the "crypt" no longer exists.

cryptolysis

Step 3:

There is a sore throat for about 1 week. However, during the healing phase, bad breath and a white plaque-like debris is seen overlying where the tonsil crypt used to be. This is NORMAL! This debris is known as eschar and it basically is a scab that's wet. (Imagine looking at a scab elsewhere on the body after you take a shower.)

cryptolysis

Step 4:

Once the area is completely healed up in about 3-4 weeks, the bad breath will resolve and the tonsil will look pretty much back to normal without the crypt (and hopefully no more tonsil stones)!


Some Actual Before and After Pictures

These pictures were obtained with the patient under general anesthesia due to a bad gag reflex. The tonsil crypts where stones were coming out from are denoted by arrowheads.

cryptolysis
Before the Procedure: 2 fairly large tonsil crypts which have been producing stones.
cryptolysis
After the Procedure: The two crypts have been completely obliterated with coblation.

 

Costs

This procedure is covered by insurance. Laser cryptolysis is performed in the office and no hospital or anesthesia charges are incurred.

HOWEVER, coblation cryptolysis is performed at Fauquier Hospital as an outpatient procedure. As such, a patient who undergoes this procedure will receive two billing statements... one from our office for the surgeon's fee and another from Fauquier Hospital for hospital charges. If sedation is needed, an additional anesthesia charge will be incurred.

Please note that our office has NO control over what charges the hospital bills for as well as how much they charge. Any complaints with hospital charges should be directed to their billing department. Again, we have no say, influence, or authority over what the hospital charges. You can reach Fauquier Hospital's finance department at 540-316-2970.

Only for those patients who do NOT have insurance, a discounted price from ONLY our office will be provided.

We should also add that our office receives absolutely NO payments, fees, or kickbacks whether financial or not from the hospital. It would be considered illegal as well (Stark Laws).

On a related note, media has written stories about this situation, especially given how surprisingly high hospital charges can be. Read a story about this issue here as well as here. Read blog article.

If You Live Far Away...

At this time, we are accepting new patients from Virginia, West Virginia, Maryland, and DC only. You can appeal this limitation by sending us an email. Appeals by phone will NOT be accepted. In only very rare and selective cases have we made exceptions. Read why we instituted this policy.

We do not maintain a list of physicians who offer this procedure throughout the United States. Your best bet is to contact your local ENT and ask if they or anybody they know offers this locally to where you live. This website maintains a list of providers as well, but we do not vouch for or know whether it is accurate or not.

Tonsil

Also, please be aware that should you wish to see Dr. Chang, this procedure is generally NOT performed on the same day of the visit. The procedure (which is performed only on Friday afternoons if unsedated) will be scheduled only after Dr. Chang performs an intial evaluation. If you live far away, please email Dr. Chang your interest along with a picture of your tonsils to ensure you are a candidate for the procedure (if you are not a good candidate, we do not want to waste your time and expense to see us). When you take the picture, make sure it looks like the picture shown to the right with full exposure of the tonsils and uvula (use a tongue blade if you have to). If you have a bad gag reflex and as such, not able to take the picture as shown here, you are not a good candidate for the procedure performed without sedation (it will have to be done in the operating room under general anesthesia and intubation with correspondingly much higher costs).

PLEASE keep in mind that at least for our practice, follow-up visits after the procedure is recommended. If you are not willing to commit to possible follow-up appointments, do NOT make an appointment with us. Why are we requiring this? After this procedure, it is not unusual that a patient may experience some problems or encounter a situation in which they are not sure what to do. In this scenario, it is very difficult if not impossible to answer questions over the phone without an examination leading to frustration and even anger (as follow-up examinations are very inconvenient especially if you live far away). As such, do NOT make an appointment with us unless you are willing to commit to follow-up visits. Although not mandatory, a routine follow-up appointment is generally made for 2 weeks after the procedure.


DID YOU KNOW that a person has a total of FOUR tonsils... one adenoid, two tonsils, and one lingual tonsil. The lingual tonsil is located on the back of the tongue. When lingual tonsils start to cause problems, they also can be removed.

If your tonsils and/or adenoids are affecting your quality of life, please contact our office for an appointment.

Reference:
Christopher Y. Chang, Thrasher R. Coblation Cryptolysis to Treat Tonsil Stones. ENT Journal. 91(6):238-240. June 2012.

Related Blog Articles


Related Articles Readers Have Viewed


Items to help clean out tonsil stones:


Any information provided on this website should not be considered medical advice or a substitute for a consultation with a physician. If you have a medical problem, contact your local physician for diagnosis and treatment. Advertisements present are clearly labelled and in no way support the website or influence the contents.

Recommend this Webpage to Others
By Clicking +1!


Join Us on Facebook!
facebook


Comments